Score Audit Detail

Alpha Research — AI-Generated Analysis

This audit trail is part of an alpha-stage research prototype. The sub-component scores, normalization parameters, and source attributions were generated using AI analysis of legislative texts with human advisory input. The data and model have not been independently verified.

• Do not use these breakdowns to make policy, legal, or administrative conclusions
• Composition Diversity scores are AI-assessed and may not reflect actual member composition
• Source text excerpts are paraphrased from legislative provisions, not direct quotes
• The Lanka Data Foundation (LDF) accepts no responsibility for any decisions based on this analysis

← Back to Scorecard

Health Services Act (1952) — GCS 0.040 [F]Medical Wants Ordinance (1912) — GCS 0.066 [F]Mental Disease Ordinance (1873) — GCS 0.054 [F]National Health Development Fund Act (1981) — GCS 0.129 [F]Medical Ordinance (1927) — GCS 0.132 [F]Nursing Homes (Regulations) Act (1949) — GCS 0.025 [F]Private Medical Institutions (Registration) Act (2006) — GCS 0.286 [D]Sri Lanka Nurses' Council Act (1988) — GCS 0.447 [C]Transplantation of Human Tissues Act (1987) — GCS 0.096 [F]Poisons, Opium & Dangerous Drugs Ordinance (1929) — GCS 0.053 [F]Food Act (1980) — GCS 0.136 [F]National Authority on Tobacco and Alcohol Act (2006) — GCS 0.481 [C]National Medicines Regulatory Authority Act (2015) — GCS 0.293 [D]Sri Jayewardenepura General Hospital Board Act (1983) — GCS 0.216 [F]Vijaya Kumaratunga Memorial Hospital Board Act (1999) — GCS 0.300 [D]1990 Suwaseriya Foundation Act (2018) — GCS 0.599 [B]Ayurveda Act (1961) — GCS 0.180 [F]Homoeopathy Act (1970) — GCS 0.000 [F]Health Administration

Health Services Act (1952)

Health Administration — 3 bodies

0.040F

▶1. Mandate Completeness (MCS)Weight: 30%MCS = 0.401

Component	Raw	Max	Normalized	Weight	Contribution
Bodies Count Number of distinct statutory bodies established by this act.	3	6	0.500 0.500 01 Max = 6 (the most bodies any single health act creates). Score = raw/6.	0.25	0.125
Total Powers Total number of enumerated powers across all statutory bodies.	6	27	0.222 0.222 01 Max = 27 (highest total powers in any health act). Score = raw/27.	0.25	0.056
Governance Depth Number of governance tiers (e.g., Minister → Board → Committee → Sub-committee).	3	5	0.600 0.600 01 Max = 5 tiers. Score = raw/5.	0.20	0.120
Functional Breadth Number of distinct functional categories (policy, regulatory, advisory, operational, etc.).	2	6	0.333 0.333 01 Max = 6 categories. Score = raw/6.	0.20	0.067
Cross-Linkage Number of explicit cross-references to other acts or institutions.	1	3	0.333 0.333 01 Max = 3 linkages. Score = raw/3.	0.10	0.033
MCS Total					0.401

▶2. Institutional Vitality (IVS)Weight: 35%IVS = 0.529

Health CouncilNational Policy Council (0.4)IVS = 0.725unknown

Meeting Clarity1.00w=0.30

1.000

01

1.0ClearAct specifies explicit meeting frequency (e.g., "at least once per month")

0.5VagueAct mentions meetings but without frequency (e.g., "from time to time")

0.0NoneNo mention of meeting requirements in the act

At least once per month

Quorum Defined0.00w=0.20

0.000

01

1.0YesAct defines a specific quorum number or fraction for valid decisions

0.0NoNo quorum requirement specified in the act

Not specified in Act

Reporting Mandated1.00w=0.20

1.000

01

1.0YesAct mandates reporting to a higher authority (e.g., Minister, Parliament)

0.0NoNo reporting obligation specified in the act

Secretary to the Ministry after each meeting

Dissent Protected1.00w=0.15

1.000

01

1.0YesAct allows members to record dissenting opinions or written objections

0.0NoNo provision for dissent recording in the act

Members can record written dissent with reasons

Ex-officio0.50w=0.15

0.500

01

1.0ElectedChair is elected by body members — maximizes independence

0.7Appointed (independent)Chair appointed by Minister but from outside the body

0.5Ex-officioChair is an ex-officio government official — dual loyalties possible

0.0UnknownChair selection not specified in the act

Director of Health Services (non-voting)

Body IVS = 0.725

Regional Hospitals BoardOperational Steering Unit (0.2)IVS = 0.000superseded

Meeting Clarity0.00w=0.30

0.000

01

1.0ClearAct specifies explicit meeting frequency (e.g., "at least once per month")

0.5VagueAct mentions meetings but without frequency (e.g., "from time to time")

0.0NoneNo mention of meeting requirements in the act

Unknown

Quorum Defined0.00w=0.20

0.000

01

1.0YesAct defines a specific quorum number or fraction for valid decisions

0.0NoNo quorum requirement specified in the act

Unknown

Reporting Mandated0.00w=0.20

0.000

01

1.0YesAct mandates reporting to a higher authority (e.g., Minister, Parliament)

0.0NoNo reporting obligation specified in the act

Unknown

Dissent Protected0.00w=0.15

0.000

01

1.0YesAct allows members to record dissenting opinions or written objections

0.0NoNo provision for dissent recording in the act

Unknown

Unknown0.00w=0.15

0.000

01

1.0ElectedChair is elected by body members — maximizes independence

0.7Appointed (independent)Chair appointed by Minister but from outside the body

0.5Ex-officioChair is an ex-officio government official — dual loyalties possible

0.0UnknownChair selection not specified in the act

Unknown

Body IVS = 0.000

Hospital CommitteeAdministrative Support (0.1)IVS = 0.805superseded

Meeting Clarity1.00w=0.30

1.000

01

1.0ClearAct specifies explicit meeting frequency (e.g., "at least once per month")

0.5VagueAct mentions meetings but without frequency (e.g., "from time to time")

0.0NoneNo mention of meeting requirements in the act

At least once per month

Quorum Defined1.00w=0.20

1.000

01

1.0YesAct defines a specific quorum number or fraction for valid decisions

0.0NoNo quorum requirement specified in the act

3 members

Reporting Mandated1.00w=0.20

1.000

01

1.0YesAct mandates reporting to a higher authority (e.g., Minister, Parliament)

0.0NoNo reporting obligation specified in the act

Annual report (Section 14)

Dissent Protected0.00w=0.15

0.000

01

1.0YesAct allows members to record dissenting opinions or written objections

0.0NoNo provision for dissent recording in the act

Unknown

Appointed0.70w=0.15

0.700

01

1.0ElectedChair is elected by body members — maximizes independence

0.7Appointed (independent)Chair appointed by Minister but from outside the body

0.5Ex-officioChair is an ex-officio government official — dual loyalties possible

0.0UnknownChair selection not specified in the act

Nominated by Minister (can vote)

Body IVS = 0.805

Weighted avg IVS = 0.529 (body weights: 0.4 + 0.2 + 0.1 = 0.7)

▶3. Decision Governance Quality (DGQ)Weight: 20%DGQ = 0.355

Health CouncilNational Policy Council (0.4)DGQ = 0.485

Composition Diversity0.50w=0.25

Measures how diverse the body's membership composition is (elected, appointed, ex-officio, nominated).

0.500

01

1.0HighMultiple appointment pathways (elected + appointed + ex-officio + nominated)

0.7ModerateTwo appointment types (e.g., appointed + ex-officio)

0.4LowSingle appointment type (all appointed or all ex-officio)

0.0NoneComposition not specified in the act

Director of Health Services (non-voting) + member mix

Member Sufficiency0.80w=0.15

How adequate the body's size is for effective deliberation. Score = min(maxMembers/15, 1.0) — bodies below 15 are penalized.

0.800

01

1.0Sufficient15+ members — adequate for diverse representation and sub-committees

0.5Marginal7-14 members — functional but limited capacity for specialization

0.0InadequateFewer than 7 members or size not specified

maxMembers=12, range 7-30

Power Breadth0.13w=0.30

Proportion of the body's enumerated powers vs maximum across all bodies. Score = powersCount/15.

0.133

01

1.0Comprehensive15+ distinct enumerated powers covering full governance spectrum

0.5Moderate7-14 powers — adequate operational coverage

0.0NarrowFewer than 3 powers or powers not enumerated

2 of 15 max powers

Accountability Chain0.67w=0.30

Average of three binary indicators: reporting (0/1), audit (0/1), dissent (0/1). Score = sum/3.

0.667

01

1.0FullAll three: reporting mandated + audit required + dissent protected

0.7PartialTwo of three accountability mechanisms present

0.3WeakOnly one accountability mechanism present

0.0NoneNo accountability mechanisms specified

reporting=1, audit=0, dissent=1

Body DGQ = 0.485

Regional Hospitals BoardOperational Steering Unit (0.2)DGQ = 0.115

Composition Diversity0.30w=0.25

Measures how diverse the body's membership composition is (elected, appointed, ex-officio, nominated).

0.300

01

1.0HighMultiple appointment pathways (elected + appointed + ex-officio + nominated)

0.7ModerateTwo appointment types (e.g., appointed + ex-officio)

0.4LowSingle appointment type (all appointed or all ex-officio)

0.0NoneComposition not specified in the act

Unknown + member mix

Member Sufficiency0.00w=0.15

How adequate the body's size is for effective deliberation. Score = min(maxMembers/15, 1.0) — bodies below 15 are penalized.

0.000

01

1.0Sufficient15+ members — adequate for diverse representation and sub-committees

0.5Marginal7-14 members — functional but limited capacity for specialization

0.0InadequateFewer than 7 members or size not specified

maxMembers=null, range 7-30

Power Breadth0.13w=0.30

Proportion of the body's enumerated powers vs maximum across all bodies. Score = powersCount/15.

0.133

01

1.0Comprehensive15+ distinct enumerated powers covering full governance spectrum

0.5Moderate7-14 powers — adequate operational coverage

0.0NarrowFewer than 3 powers or powers not enumerated

2 of 15 max powers

Accountability Chain0.00w=0.30

Average of three binary indicators: reporting (0/1), audit (0/1), dissent (0/1). Score = sum/3.

0.000

01

1.0FullAll three: reporting mandated + audit required + dissent protected

0.7PartialTwo of three accountability mechanisms present

0.3WeakOnly one accountability mechanism present

0.0NoneNo accountability mechanisms specified

reporting=0, audit=0, dissent=0

Body DGQ = 0.115

Hospital CommitteeAdministrative Support (0.1)DGQ = 0.315

Composition Diversity0.70w=0.25

Measures how diverse the body's membership composition is (elected, appointed, ex-officio, nominated).

0.700

01

1.0HighMultiple appointment pathways (elected + appointed + ex-officio + nominated)

0.7ModerateTwo appointment types (e.g., appointed + ex-officio)

0.4LowSingle appointment type (all appointed or all ex-officio)

0.0NoneComposition not specified in the act

Nominated by Minister (can vote) + member mix

Member Sufficiency0.00w=0.15

How adequate the body's size is for effective deliberation. Score = min(maxMembers/15, 1.0) — bodies below 15 are penalized.

0.000

01

1.0Sufficient15+ members — adequate for diverse representation and sub-committees

0.5Marginal7-14 members — functional but limited capacity for specialization

0.0InadequateFewer than 7 members or size not specified

maxMembers=null, range 7-30

Power Breadth0.13w=0.30

Proportion of the body's enumerated powers vs maximum across all bodies. Score = powersCount/15.

0.133

01

1.0Comprehensive15+ distinct enumerated powers covering full governance spectrum

0.5Moderate7-14 powers — adequate operational coverage

0.0NarrowFewer than 3 powers or powers not enumerated

2 of 15 max powers

Accountability Chain0.33w=0.30

Average of three binary indicators: reporting (0/1), audit (0/1), dissent (0/1). Score = sum/3.

0.333

01

1.0FullAll three: reporting mandated + audit required + dissent protected

0.7PartialTwo of three accountability mechanisms present

0.3WeakOnly one accountability mechanism present

0.0NoneNo accountability mechanisms specified

reporting=1, audit=0, dissent=0

Body DGQ = 0.315

Weighted avg DGQ = 0.355

▶4. Power Dormancy Index (PDI)PenaltyPDI = -0.310

Body	Status	Category Weight	Raw Penalty	Weighted Penalty
Health Council	unknown	0.4	-0.300	-0.120
Regional Hospitals Board	superseded	0.2	-0.700	-0.140
Hospital Committee	superseded	0.1	-0.500	-0.050
Total PDI				-0.310

-0.300Health Council has mandated meetings but operational status is unknown

-0.700Regional Hospitals Board has been superseded but parent act not repealed

-0.500Hospital Committee has been superseded but parent act not repealed

▶5. Data Confidence Modifier (DCM)ScalingDCM = 0.6

Legislative Framework

high

Historical Details

medium

Current Operational Status

low

Any low confidence level → 0.6

Modifier	Rule	Meaning
1.0	All three dimensions are "high"	Full confidence — score reflects reality accurately
0.8	Any dimension is "medium" (none "low")	Moderate uncertainty — score may be slightly higher/lower
0.6	Exactly one dimension is "low"	Significant gap — one data source is unreliable
0.4	Two or more dimensions are "low"	Low confidence — score is largely indicative, not definitive

DCM = 0.6

▶6. Final GCS AssemblyFormulaGCS = 0.040

0.040

0Final GCS1

raw = 0.30 × MCS + 0.35 × IVS + 0.20 × DGQ + PDI = 0.30 × 0.401 + 0.35 × 0.529 + 0.20 × 0.355 + (-0.310) = 0.120 + 0.185 + 0.071 + (-0.310) = 0.066 clamped = max(0, min(1, 0.066)) = 0.066 GCS = 0.066 × 0.6 = 0.040 → Grade F

MCS contrib:0.30 × 0.401 = 0.120

IVS contrib:0.35 × 0.529 = 0.185

DGQ contrib:0.20 × 0.355 = 0.071

PDI penalty:-0.310

Raw score:0.066

DCM applied:× 0.6

Final GCS:0.040 → Grade F

▶7. Alerts3 alerts